Rye Teacher Carin Mehler's Federal Lawsuit is Dismissed

Carin Mehler

 Previous posts on this blog:

Carin Mehler's Re-assignment in Rye Costs the District a Pretty Penny.....So, Put Her Back To Work!               

Rye Teacher Carin Mehler Sues For $1 Million After Being Placed On Administrative Leave Which Destroyed Her Reputation

Rye teacher suit dismissed by federal judge

 Swapna Venugopal Ramaswamy, svenugop@lohud.com

A federal lawsuit brought by a Rye teacher alleging her constitutional rights were violated by the school district was dismissed last week.

LINK

Previous coverage : Rye teacher: 'I have no way of defending myself'

Carin Mehler, the fourth-grade teacher who has been on paid administrative reassignment since May 2013 for improper coaching of her students during state exams, alleged in her 2014 lawsuit she was deprived of "due process."

In a decision released last week, U.S. District Court Judge Cathy Seibel said while the district did not have sufficient evidence to prove wrongdoing by Mehler, it did not violate her constitutional rights.

"The Court understands Plaintiff's frustration at the situation, and understands why the Defendants are keeping Plaintiff out of the classroom when they admittedly cannot prove wrongdoing on her part," Seibel wrote. "But not every situation that seems, or even is, unfair or ill-advised amounts to a federal constitutional violation."

(Read the decision at end of this story)

Meanwhile, Mehler is being paid $150,000 to $200,000 in salary and benefits while the Rye school district decides whether to bring formal charges against her. The lack of a charge has prevented the tenured teacher from having a state-required administrative hearing that would determine her future.

Mehler's Manhattan-based attorney, Arthur Schwartz, called the decision "very disappointing."

"There is no question in anyone's mind that her two year reassignment is punishment," Schwartz said. "But it is punishment meted out without any sort of due process."

A district spokesperson could not immediately be reached for comment.

Mehler, who taught fourth-grade at Osborn, was put on administrative reassignment along with three other teachers almost two years ago amid allegations of improper coaching during 2013 state exams. She was one of four teachers to be reassigned for "testing irregularities."

For about a year, Mehler was assigned to a room by herself, stacking books by grade level, in what the Rye Teachers Union called "solitary confinement." This year, she's been told to stay home during school hours and make fourth-grade lesson plans.

Shannon Gold, a fourth-grade teacher at Milton School who had been reassigned,resigned in January 2014. Gail Topol, a third-grade teacher at Osborn, returned to the classroom in February 2014 after paying a $2,500 fine and converting 27 days of her administrative reassignment into a paid suspension.

Dana Coppola, a third-grade teacher at Milton Elementary School, who returned to the classroom in September, was fined $18,000 in a settlement involving formal charges of 10 counts of misconduct and neglect of duty.

Read: Carin Mehler court decision

Thursday, January 8, 2015

Dear Rye School District: Put Carin Mehler Back To Work

Almost two years after she was removed from the classroom for "improper coaching" during a state exam, a fourth grade Osborne Elementary School teacher says she still doesn't know what she's accused of.
LINK

 

Rye teacher Carin Mehler was reassigned to work from her home by the Rye School district. She is shown in the dining area of her Rye home Jan. 7, 2015 where she uses a tablet to work on lesson plans. She says the district is yet to bring charges against her, and district taxpayers are paying her full salary and benefits to keep her at home.(Photo: Joe Larese/The Journal News)

RYE – Almost two years after she was removed from the classroom for "improper coaching" during a state exam, a fourth grade Osborne Elementary School teacher says she still doesn't know what she's accused of.

Carin Mehler is being paid $150,000 to $200,000 in salary and benefits while the school district decides what formal charges to bring against her, according to her lawyer, Arthur Schwartz. The lack of a charge has prevented the tenured teacher from having a state-required administrative hearing that will determine her future.

"I don't know what I did wrong," Mehler said in an exclusive interview with The Journal News - her first public statement since she and three other teachers were reassigned in May 2013. "They never questioned me, never asked me to explain anything. And I have no way of defending myself."

In Mehler's case, the district never clarified the allegation with a formal charge. For about a year, she was assigned to a room by herself, stacking books according to grade level, in what the Rye Teachers Union described as "solitary confinement."

This year, she's been told to stay home during school hours and make fourth grade lesson plans. Mehler says she doesn't know if the district is actually using any of her work.

"They don't even acknowledge my emails," she said.

On Thursday, Rye district spokeswoman Sarah Derman, said she didn't know when charges might be filed.

In the 2013-14 school year, after the four teachers were reassigned for improper coaching, the board contracted with four "leave-replacement" teachers at a total $272, 834, to fill their spots.

By September, the district had settled with the other reassigned teachers.

Asked how much was being spent to fill Mehler's spot this school year, Derman said that it was not a "seat for seat exchange per se," but that the annual average salary of the leave replacements at Osborn is approximately $68,000, plus the cost of health insurance.

While the district hasn't filed formal charges, it did respond to Mehler's federal lawsuit last year, saying that a parent had expressed concern about her child receiving help during the state assessments. The district also claimed that at least four students gave specific and detailed examples of how Mehler assisted them.

"Mehler reviewed the students' answers and suggested to students that they may want to change their answers, told students to add more detail to their answers and to check spelling, capitals and punctuations, told students to make their essays longer and explain things better, told students they did not need a protractor for questions and told students they did not need to measure to answer certain questions," the district said.

Mehler denied the allegation.

"I have always followed the testing protocol strictly," she said, adding that it was ludicrous to think that 9-year-olds interviewed days after the alleged incident could be accurate, particularly when they had taken a slew of practice tests before the actual state exam.

Rye Teachers Union President Jamie Zung said last year that schools Superintendent Frank Alvarez tried to persuade parents to let their children be interviewed almost a year after the alleged incident.

In New York City, teachers must be formally charged under section 3020-a within 60 days from being reassigned for misconduct. For the rest of the state, the districts have three years to bring charges, said Arthur Schwartz, Mehler's attorney.

"They could not treat Carin this way in New York City," said Schwartz.

Mehler, a North Rockland High School graduate who grew up in Thieles, said the episode had taken a toll on her family and her parents.

"My mother lives in Rockland and my in-laws live in New Rochelle. It is embarrassing for all of us," she said, adding that the situation has caused a lot of anxiety for her youngest daughter, a fifth-grader at Osborn.

"Teaching is all know," Mehler said. "I miss it so much. My biggest career goal was to be named 'Teacher of The Year' and to think that I might never teach again is heartbreaking. They can keep me out of the classroom forever if they want."

Boukje van den Bosch-Smits, an Osborn parent who has been a stalwart champion of Mehler's, has regularly demanded answers at school board meetings.

"They are dumping our money into the ocean and keeping a great teacher away from her classroom," she said.

Shannon Gold, a fourth-grade teacher at Milton who had been reassigned, resigned last January. Gail Topol, a third-grade teacher at Osborn, returned to the classroom in February after paying a fine of $2,500 and converting 27 days of her administrative reassignment to a paid suspension. Dana Coppola, who returned to the classroom in September, was fined $18,000 as part of a settlement.

Coppola, a third-grade teacher at Milton Elementary School, had been part of Mehler's federal and state lawsuits, but dropped out as part of her settlement; the state case was dismissed last month.

Mehler said that the district's delaying tactics are meant to coerce her into a settlement, but that she won't back down.

Topol and Coppola agreed to pay fines in exchange for being reinstated, she said, but she won't consider that option.

"I am not paying a dime for something I didn't do," Mehler said.