The best argument against keeping Mayoral control over the NYC public schools is in yesterday's (June 1, 2016) NY POST - see below.
The corruption of Mayor Bill de Blasio and his sidekick, Carmen Farina. The two of them have managed to do more damage to the students of New York City than any Mayor in recent history, the truth will come out. No, I haven't forgotton about Bloomberg's scandal with CityTime.... but I still think the Bill-Carmen team is worse). The PEP puppets harm NYC public schools and the parents/children under their direction and authority.
Bill and Carmen must not be left at the top without public supervision - give them monitors or something? Put them under 24-hour watch.
But get rid of the PEP, and give us back a vote for school board members. I believe in no taxation/vexation without representation. July 4th is nearly here.
I agree with the judgment given by the NY Court of Appeals ( 281 N.Y. 170; 22 N.E.2d 327; 1939 N.Y. LEXIS 994) in the case Divisich et al., Appellants, v. James Marshall et al., Constituting the Board of Education of the City of New York, Respondents:
"Public education shall be beyond control by municipalities and politics. The Board of Education of the City of New York is not a department of the city government, it is an independent corporate body and may sue and be sued in its corporate name. N.Y. Educ. Law §§ 300, 865. While the municipality must make appropriations of money to run the schools, the expenditure of that money when once appropriated vests solely in the educational board."
Editor, NYC Rubber Room Reporter
Editor, New York Court Corruption
Editor, National Public Voice
|NYC Chancellor Carmen Farina|
Senate Majority Leader John Flanagan sponsored the bill, which was quietly introduced to the Senate on Friday.
The bill by the Senate GOP, which has been warring with de Blasio, would create a new position of New York City education inspector that would be appointed not by the mayor, but the governor, with consent from the Senate.
According to the bill, which is sponsored by Senate Majority Leader John Flanagan and Education Committee Chairman Carl Marcellino, the education inspector would provide "oversight, guidance, and technical assistance related to the educational and fiscal policies, practices, programs, and decisions of the city district, city board, chancellor, and mayor."
The appointed inspector would need some kind of background in education and would serve, along with the schools chancellor, as a non-voting member of the city board. The inspector would be entitled to attend all board meetings, including executive sessions.
The inspector, according to the bill, would have access to all educational facilities and records and could impose monthly reporting requirements on the board, chancellor or Department of Education.
The gubernatorial appointee would also be able to appeal any decision by the city board to the state education commissioner, with the board being required to demonstrate their action was in the best interests of the students.
The inspector would also be required to evaluate and make recommendations on a wide range of issues, including how funds are distributed, disciplinary actions against students and teachers, and the co-location of charter schools.
He or she would also look into the effectiveness of programs for the disabled and English Language learners, and how well the city is engaging parents and community members.
The evaluation results and recommendations would be reported to the governor and legislative leaders.
With the mayoral control law set to expire at the end of June, the Senate bill would extend it another year through June 30, 2017 — smack in the middle of de Blasio's re-election campaign.
The bill would also require the city to regularly provide state leaders a trove of information on student and teacher data and expenditures as well as develop a facilities capital plan that identifies the 10 most overcrowded and underutilized school buildings.
A de Blasio spokeswoman said City Hall would not support the Senate bill.
"The successes we're seeing in our schools are the direct result of accountable mayoral control," spokeswoman Karen Hinton said. "To deny New York City’s 1.1 million students anything less than the full preservation of mayoral control is to subject them to the dysfunction and chaos of the old system, as well as risk an end to higher test scores and graduation rates. We urge once again the swift approval of this proven governance structure.”
Gov. Cuomo's office did not comment immediately.
The Assembly, which recently passed its own bill that would extend mayoral control another three years, also opposes the Senate measure.
De Blasio, state Senate argue over mayoral control of NYC schools
"They weren't interested in placing conditions on mayoral control when Mayor Bloomberg was in office," said Michael Whyland spokesman for Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie. "We support a straight extension."
The matter must be resolved before the scheduled June 16 end of the legislative session or the law will expire and the city school system would revert back to the old Board of Education days.